viewpoints.xyz

viewpoints.xyz
Vote

Can collective intelligence solve alignment?

Could a system that's designed to reward the evaluation of propositions be used to align ASI?

12 people have given 102 responses

Statements with the highest number of 👍 or the highest number of 👎 appear at the top (if everyone thinks 👎, that's consensus too)

We should have been paying people to get an education all along.

67%
17%
17%

We don't know how to control machine learning.

67%
33%

A polling system (like this) could be used in theory to align AI.

40%
60%

Crypto credentials will replace money.

57%
14%
29%

Our children should be able to earn a living by educating themselves in ways society desires.

57%
0%
43%

We should not relinquish the job of 'deciding what the AI ought do' to AI.

57%
14%
29%

It's very important that the AI is able to distinguish what IP can from which user.

57%
0%
43%

AI is going to take all the jobs if we let it.

50%
17%
33%

A polling system like this could be implemented into social media to scale a project like CYC.

50%
0%
50%

Determining the beliefs of 8 billion free individuals is required to build an AI that's aligned to all of them.

38%
50%
13%

If it asks enough T/F questions, an AI can find out anything about your beliefs.

50%
50%

All historical advancement is collective, and so asking "can CI solve alignment" is the same as asking "can we solve alignment".

33%
50%
17%

The truth can be approximated by a series of proposition evaluations.

50%
17%
33%

Verification and education are two sides of the same coin.

33%
17%
50%

Creating a truth economy (an economy where the majority of value comes from the verification of truth) is critical to the survival of the humanity.

33%
17%
50%

If Doug Lenat's work would have scaled, Eliezer Yudkowsky would not have existential concerns about it.

29%
0%
71%